Final Four Finalist
"America's Best Card Shop" 2022

30 Years in Business

Since 1992, Baseball Card Connection has served central Illinois and collectors worldwide by providing high quality trading cards and sports memorabilia.

Over 10 Million Cards in Inventory

Our store has moved three times in order to keep up with demand for retail space. We finally landed in our current location in downtown Effingham.

6,000-Square-Foot Showroom

We hope you can visit our retail store in person. If you are unable to travel, you are always just a few seconds away from our eBay and Beckett online stores.

Baseball Player
Baseball Card Connection Store

Have a collection to sell?

Baseball Cards

We’d be happy to talk to you about purchasing your collection. There are several eras and sets we are interested in, along with other types of memorabilia. Stop by, call, or email us if you have any questions. Click below to find out more about what we buy.


Babe Ruth Baseball

Follow us

Keep up to date with events, shows, breaks, collectibles, and other happenings in the Baseball Card Connection Universe!